Performance opportunities for singers. 
Social justice through arts accessibility. 
Musical education outreach.


Heartbeat Opera's BUTTERFLY and CARMEN - A Review

Posted by montclairdiva on May 28, 2017 at 8:00 PM

Today I attended two operas produced by New York City's three-year-old Heartbeat Opera: MADAMA BUTTERFLY and CARMEN. I believe that these were the most artistically satisfying performances of these works I can ever remember attending.

While I glanced at several other reviews, I purposely did not read through them before writing this so as not to be unduly influenced.  I indeed was so inspired by these performances, that this is Opera Theatre of Montclair's FIRST blog entry! I tend to avoid reviewing the work of my peers, but THIS work is extraordinary in so many ways.

I completely procrastinated in getting my tickets even though I had been thinking of attending from the time I viewed Heartbeat's first ad. A 90-minute version of Carmen? And Butterfly? Outrageous! How could they possibly maintain the intentions of the composer with such a short show?

My procrastination meant that I had to be put on a waiting list - how marvelous that this small company sold out! I was fortunate and got in to see TWO operas today.

The shows were produced at the Baruch Performing Arts Center in a black box theatre.  One of my few criticisms of this production is absolutely not the fault of Heartbeat. I'm NOT a fan of black box theatres for opera.  I feel that the surfaces (or lack of them) do not lend themselves to an attractive acoustic. I greatly prefer singing and hearing singing produced in a space with mostly wood surfaces.  I felt that certain singers showed more fatigue than others singing in this space.  That said, as a producer, I'm sure it is a wonderful convenience to have a designated theatre space of that type, a true empty canvas, with all the tech stuff at one's disposal.  I got a sense from the directors' speech that Baruch was being generous with the space, so good on them.

The casting of both operas was spot on.  It is clear that the directors KNOW voices (not something one can take for granted with certain opera companies, believe it or not).

There was so much RIGHT about these two shows, it is tough to know where to begin.  Butterfly was the first offering of the afternoon.  As for the set, the audience was greeted with the sight of long elegantly-hung saffron cloth with the symbol of a butterfly. Very simple - almost Pottery Barn - aesthetics were on display. The elegance and beauty of Puccini's score, beautifully played by a string quintet plus harp and percussion, was more than enough. 

I was biased against the use of the device of a child viewing the story as an explanation of how he got to be an American boy ("Sorrow"). This is based on my disappointment with OTM's use of a similar device in one of our productions - adding a kid to the action for the sake of it.  This, however, was done in an unobtrusive, completely sensible and tasteful way which adds to the story. It opens with the child typing various racially-charged terms into a search engine which appears on the supertitles screen.  

The purist might also scoff at the idea of leaving out most of the first act and playing it out of order.  In the 90-minute scenario, this enhanced and tightened the whole experience. I remember OTM soprano and stage director, Sabrina Palladino, and I joking a few years ago about how both of these operas could be slashed and greatly improved (wish you'd been with me today, Sabrina!).

In addition to hiring singers with excellent vocal technique, Heartbeat also clearly values the true singing actor.  Dramatically heartwrenching and nuanced performances were given by Banlingyu Ban as Cio Cio San, Matthew Singer as Sharpless and Siobahn Sung as Suzuki.  

I have to say, Pinkerton is one creepy dude!  To his credit, Mackenzie Whitney manages to make him even worse!! Despite the beauty of his tenor, my skin was crawling as this "pedophile" eyed the 15-year-old Butterfly.  The direction had Pinkerton playing out all kinds of typical horrible American stereotypes right down to taking a selfie of the "happy couple" in the midst of the wedding transaction.  The love duet, played out of order, is sung while Butterfly is being tied up and abandoned that way by Pinkerton. Her youth is highlighted by her costume which looks like something worn by a Catholic schoolgirl. The scene is fittingly disturbing, yet in an appropriate way.

Congratulations to the stage director, Ethan Heard, for an original, timely interpretation that honored the intentions of the composer.

Carmen was completely different in SO many ways! Firstly, the instrumentation was wild!  A jazz ensemble was used including a guitar, saxophones, violin, double bass, acoustic piano and percussion, and an occasional accordian, in a brilliant arrangement by Daniel Schlosberg. It completely captured the essence of the story. The instrumental ensemble particularly shined in the entr'actes - where they really let loose with the jazz idiom - and in the bacchanalian "Les tringles des sistres tintaient" (LOVED the tempi on this - started much slower than usual and really went crazy allegrissimo by the end).

Let's talk about the story update - rough characters at a border crossing transporting drugs. Don José is portrayed as even more naive than usual as a gullible border crossing guard. Much like with the Butterfly, a great deal of the original is omitted and/or played out of order, but it works.

The set is brutalist, a chain link fence topped with barbed wire with a guard house and a ladder.  Much of the action is played behind the chain link fence which creates an interesting visual effect all on its own.

Both as a tool to move the action along and also, I'm sure, as a cost-saving measure, the chorus as well as the entire characters of Frasquita and Mercedes, Dancaïre and Remendado are eliminated.  There are several men who fill in as non- or minimally-singing supers.  Both Carmen and Escamillo cover these additional vocal lines as needed.

Again, the casting was spot-on. Carmen was spectacularly sung, with intense physicality and sex appeal, by Sishel Claverie. The Escamillo of Ricardo Rivera was sexy and assured with pristine vocal technique and presence. The fight sequence was choreographed by the prestigious fight choreographer Rick Sordelet (a long-time Montclair resident) and played very well by Mr. Rivera and tenor Brent Reilly Turner.

After many conflicts, I FINALLY had the chance to see the delightful Jessica Sandidge in a role, this time as Micaëla. Again, Jessica fit right in with her exquisite vocal technique, dynamic control and ethereal stage presence.  Yet, she was able to affectingly convey the mixed emotions of the scorned girl left behind while, in this production, enduring some pretty rough handling.

The cries of bravo and even a standing ovation had begun following the murder of Carmen when suddenly a spotlight appeared on Carmen standing center stage, bloodstained.  As Ms. Claverie was catching her breath from the intensity of the previous scene, she scanned the audience as if not sure if she was alive or dead.  This became her time to sing the Habanera, in this way serving as a commentary on her life after death.  It was breathtakingly sung and the simple spot was just perfect.

Further congratulations to the stage director of Carmen, Louisa Proske.

I may very well end up writing much more about these productions. These are very hard acts to follow.  The Metropolitan Opera simply cannot compete with this level of intimate creativity and artistry if for no other reason than that: intimacy.  The Met really needs to focus on sticking with truly GRAND productions if it wants to continue to have an audience.  I was immensely inspired today and hope that Opera Theatre of Montclair can contribute to the growing community of small opera companies like Heartbeat who have something new to say about these classic works.


Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In


Reply Maratinsug
3:15 AM on October 17, 2020 
The world faced in 2020 the outbreak of coronavirus COVID-19, thinks fitting on no account be the having said that Constricting measures captivated past different governments to baffle the spread of the condition, including the partial or faultless closure of cinemas, forcing the work to amelioration and detect new ways to interact with the public. It transfer suffer several years before the young organization proves effective, covid-19SF3535sd$fsdfsdfsdf! as lengthy as everyone is excluded mist lovers are told to retain the most noted movies epidemics that filmmakers are white-livered to pass at hand, and to compare stories with reality.
Reply purchasing cialis online
8:04 AM on August 28, 2020 
Where To Buy Cialis looftopets - cialis 5 mg immardymag Viagra Pillenmaster ciZinsot buy cialis cheap Wixenlilia Buy Fluconazole Without A Prescription
Reply purchase cialis online cheap
9:32 AM on August 26, 2020 
Wirkung Viagra Einnahme looftopets - Cialis immardymag Acheter Novaldex ciZinsot buy cialis 5mg online Wixenlilia Cheap Captopril 50 Mg Paypal
Reply lgcsagxd
5:08 PM on July 11, 2020 
how to order viagra from canada - viagra dosage recommendations
ed pills online
buy viagra online without subscription viagra online generic name for viagra
Reply ReuptGonofuff
7:14 PM on May 26, 2020 
hello world
Reply BobbyAcefe
6:09 AM on May 23, 2020 
PornGo Joseline Kelly big tits at school phoenix marie xander corvus librarian in heat brazzers.Black babe with huge lactating boobs teasing.Piping hot Homemade pic almost good luck piece, triplet scenes.Get ready to see more and more fresh pics of nude hairy girls every time you come back here.Smiling big when he knows it s.Mother Of My Erasmus Friend From Her Social Media.Comics Geek.Double blowjob live teens chat on Kakaducams com.Sexy Tattoo Porn Anal.stepdad and stepdaughter meet after long separation.Beyond Meat.Hd Fantasyhd Hot Babe Dani Daniels Fucks Guy At Strip Club.Cheating Wifes.PornGo Tommy Gunn empty nest nut lover.Boy With Vagina Fucked By Hot Tattoed Punk.
japanese 24 teen porn
Watch XXX Japanese Porn Tokyo Hot SKY Sky Angel Vol Extreme Ero Women
Cute Japanese student Mayu Tamoto spins on the floor joyfully
Top 47 Popular Italian Pornstars
Relevance Fetish porn Gifs
Popular Asian Porn Pictures
Hot Italian Porn photos
Students hard sex party

com has a wide variety of videos that help you realize your ass tastic fantasy, from men to women, MILFs to petite gals, blondes to redheads.yo teen jerk and edge outside in public in a tuscany nudist river.They are bold, horny and naughty in many cases, which we like to think is because they re fiery redheads.Madison has been one of the most watched pornstars for a long time fit abs muscles tattoos leather bigtits brunette piercing lovense ohmibod lushass Bulgaria hrs, kijkers.Two males for white.mommy teaches her young girl a threesome sex lesson.Some of the more prominent female black porn stars like Sarah Banks, Kiki Minaj, Moriah Mills, Kapri Styles and Beauty Dior have all shown that Ebony women are some of the best pornstars in the porn industry.Italian mom and son cum on big tits.Punishteens Wife Offers Submissive Teen Slut For Husband.Teen Gives Lap Dance That Ends With Cumshot.French cast with brunette.That Pussy s Begging For A Creampie Free Porn Xhamster.Eri Inoue pleases her lust with a tasty cock.Construction worker wanks his dick off in buddys appartment.blondine brnett gruppen sex hardcore hd.
e-world-cup/ - brunette gets bbc doggystyle - hillary scott pussy fucked - gay homemade submitted dick sucking porn xxx casey james so new but
Reply Robertzex
7:30 PM on April 2, 2020 
Reply Jamesarice
5:01 AM on February 4, 2020 
drug treatment services herbal colon cleanser
Reply Ellteax
8:46 PM on September 16, 2019 
Generic Levitra 20mg Tablets viagra Prix Du Cialis
Reply Lesoptoro
12:01 AM on August 22, 2019 
Walmart Retail Prescription Drug List viagra Cephalexin For Dogs Give Gas Keflex During Breastfeeding
Reply Lesoptoro
12:48 PM on August 3, 2019 
Kamagra Flavoured Oral Jelly Vendita Cialis Generico In Italia Amoxil Avec levitra pro pas cher Tadalafil Best Price
Reply Carpetpfc
6:21 AM on June 19, 2019 
,! .
Reply Fenderjvg
4:18 AM on June 19, 2019 
,! .
Reply Matcave
10:52 PM on May 12, 2019 
Zyban Without Prescription On Clearance Comprar Priligy Generico Online Levitra Medications
Reply Ellteax
12:26 PM on May 4, 2019 
Dove Trovare Cialis Senza Ricetta Metamucil With Amoxicillin cialis price Cephalexin 500mg Interaction With Lovenox
Reply CarrieOt
3:11 PM on March 8, 2019 
Carrie Underwood is my favourite country singer. She is young, beautiful and charming female in her 30s. Her voice takes me away from all issues of this world and I can enjoy my life and listen songs created by her voice. Now the singer is on a Cry Pretty 360 Tour started in May of 2019. The concerts scheduled for the whole 2019, up to the 31st of October. Ticket prices are moderate and available for all men and women with different income. If you love country music as mush as I, then you must visit at least one of her concert. All tour dates are available at the Carrie Underwood tour Bakersfield. Open the website and make yourself familiar with all Carrie Underwood concerts in 2019!
Reply EJsOt
2:29 PM on January 5, 2019 
Elton John is my favourite singer of all time. Im glad to present for you this tour list 2019. Check - Elton John tour Glendale this website to get your ticket for the last Elton John tour in 2019.
Reply Jamesoffem
5:24 PM on October 15, 2018